A Tempting Online Deal Could Be Your Biggest Loss

Buying a car through platforms like Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, or OfferUp can be tempting due to potentially lower prices. Unfortunately, for San Diegans, there are specific risks and challenges:

1. Lack of Transparency and Local Regulation

These platforms lack the oversight and regulations of established dealerships and reputable dealers. For example, the requirement to make a profile on Craigslist is an email. That would be the first step the seller takes when hoping to sell you a car. This is in contrast to the fact that locally, we require multiple business and sales licenses from dealers already serving our community. In California, car dealerships are subject to various DMV inspections and fines for non-compliance. These are the type of fines that could put a store out of business. Why wouldn't we have the same standards for the 2nd largest purchase of our lives? Buy it from your uncle, mom, or cousin before you buy it here. 

Below is the story of two local San Diego men getting scammed at the same time by a man pretending to be both the buyer and seller. He ends up stealing $14,000 in cash in broad daylight. The police believe they are familiar with what they are doing and might still be trying to scam people on Craigslist: Craigslist car scam costs victim nearly $15K

 Sellers might not disclose accurate information about the car's condition, history, or title status, leading to potential surprises after purchase. Why would they? This could be by mistake or on purpose so this adds an extra layer of difficulty to navigate. I've seen posts on reddit explaining sellers online going as far as to post highly edited photographs to hide damage. This guy here has had it with private sellers and took his grievances to r/UsedCars: Why does it feel like everyone selling a used car is a scammer?

Make sure to ask for all relevant service information. For example, request the vehicle's maintenance records, title, and any relevant documentation to verify its history and ownership.

2. Potential Fraud and Recent Scams

There's a higher risk of encountering scams or fraudulent listings. Some sellers might try to sell stolen vehicles, misrepresent the car's condition, or engage in other fraudulent activities, leaving buyers vulnerable to financial loss.

You should do what you can to verify the seller or buyer's information. Confirm the seller's identity and contact information. Be cautious of sellers who avoid disclosing certain details or provide inconsistent information. This can be an easy red flag that can guide your decision-making.

3. Limited Consumer Protections

Unlike buying from licensed dealerships, purchasing from private sellers on these platforms offers limited legal recourse if issues arise post-purchase. Consumer protections and warranty options are often absent or minimal. Often, buyers have to take a seller's word for crucial information.

Negotiate wisely. Research comparable vehicles' prices and use that information to negotiate a fair price. Don't rush into making a deal; take your time to consider your options.

4. Safety Concerns

 

Meeting strangers for test drives or transactions can pose safety risks for anyone. San Diegans might feel uncomfortable meeting unfamiliar individuals in far locations for car inspections or test drives while apps give off the appearance of a safe and easy platform to buy a car.

If you or a family member MUST buy a car through these platforms, here are some crucial safety tips to consider:

• Meet in a safe location like a police station or shopping center.

• Bring a trusted companion instead of going alone.

• Don't give out personal information such as phone number, email, and address. Use In-app messaging to communicate securely.

• Avoid cash transactions. If possible, use a secure payment method like a cashier's check or a money order to avoid carrying large sums of cash.

5. Unknown Vehicle Histories

Most private sellers on these platforms do not provide comprehensive vehicle history reports. This lack of information about past accidents, maintenance records, or potential recalls can lead to unforeseen issues.

It is already difficult enough for San Diegans to find a reliable car. Even trusted 3rd party reporting like CarFax comes with a list of inaccuracies that could leave a buyer with a bad car purchase. If you want to avoid a financial mistake because you only went by CarFax, read my post on Why CarFax Is The Least Reliable Car Buying Resource.

6. Higher Chance of Mechanical Issues

Without proper inspection by a trusted mechanic, buyers might overlook potential mechanical issues or hidden damages, resulting in costly repairs shortly after the purchase.

Make it a priority to drive and inspect the car. Insist on a test drive and a thorough inspection inside and out. Look for signs of wear, rust, leaks, or any mechanical issues.

7. Complex Title and Registration Processes

San Diego's specific regulations for vehicle title transfers and registrations might add complexity to the process when buying from private sellers on these platforms, potentially leading to legal or administrative issues.

 

Fortunately, there are plenty of alternatives with easier registration steps for San Diegans. Which means less time at the DMV!

 

Here are 4 alternatives to buying a car on Craigslist, OfferUp, or Facebook Marketplace:

1. Certified Preowned Dealerships: Consider reputable dealerships that offer certified pre-owned vehicles with warranties and thorough inspections.
2. Online Market with Buyer Protection: Look for online platforms like Carvana or Vroom, which provide a selection of used cars with buyer protection policies and thorough inspections.
3. Auto Auctions: Attend local auto auctions, but be cautious as these might have limited or no guarantees on the vehicle's condition.
4. Car Rental Companies: Some car rental companies sell their used fleet directly to consumers, offering well-maintained vehicles with comprehensive records.

While these platforms may offer great-looking deals and easy-to-use interfaces, San Diegans should exercise caution, conduct thorough research, and consider the potential risks before buying a car through Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, or OfferUp. Opting for reputable dealerships or certified pre-owned vehicles can provide more security, transparency, and peace of mind in the car-buying process.

 

Personally, as an experienced car dealer, I wouldn't waste my time with sites like these, The risk is much greater than the reward. I cringe at the thought of a parent purchasing a car for their new teen driver from these sites. Cars are crucial lifelines in San Diego. They are way too important to cheap out on.

 

If you like my insight on the car buying process, subscribe to my blog for more posts like these. Check out my $100 Gas Card Referral Offer. You can read more about here.